Saturday October 11 2008
Sony Playstation 3

GotFrag Madden Forums

MGS4 scores an 8

1
13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

from Edge magazine. Halo3 > MGS4 confirmed?
"GTA4 ALL 10's" - IGN
2
37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking
+1 Frags
+   -

Confirmed.
3
63% Ranking 63% Ranking 63% Ranking 63% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Confirmed.
4
11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking 11% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Halo 3 better than MGS4?

Well, I dunno about that... Halo 3, just like the previous two Halo games, is freakishly overrated.

But am I surprised at the prospect that MGS4 could be a victim of overhype, along with the realization that Hideo Kojima's MGS games are also incredibly overrated (albeit not quite so much as Halo)?

Not at all. I've been saying that for years, ever since MGS2.

This comment was edited at 05/31/2008 4:33 PM
5
61% Ranking 61% Ranking 61% Ranking 61% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Confirmed.
Gamertag: t0va
6
68% Ranking 68% Ranking 68% Ranking 68% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

MGS4 will be awesome.
"GUY"s are stupid. EMO_GUY needs to cut himself.
7
60% Ranking 60% Ranking 60% Ranking 60% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

lol u guys are pathetic... if u really need reviews to justify your MGS4 purchase, you are not a metal gear fan. EDGE reviews harder than any magazine.
fuck the pats
8
12% Ranking 12% Ranking 12% Ranking 12% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

# 7 got that right ... If u like the series u are gonna buy the game , simple as that
9
37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking 37% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

omg it's not a 10 well f that im not purchasing that trash



agreed with #7 btw
z4QQQandthebatmansymbol
10
61% Ranking 61% Ranking 61% Ranking 61% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

oh come on scoobs...they gave halo3 a fVcking 10!
Gamertag: t0va

12
68% Ranking 68% Ranking 68% Ranking 68% Ranking
-1 Frags
+   -

If you go by hype then no game will ever live up to it #11
"GUY"s are stupid. EMO_GUY needs to cut himself.
13
84% Ranking 84% Ranking 84% Ranking 84% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

9.9 (lol) @ IGN.UK
Senior Editor - http://www.fpslabs.com
14
72% Ranking 72% Ranking 72% Ranking 72% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

That 9.9 is jokes. They just couldn't give it a 10 and yet somehow Halo3 and GTA4 got 10's.

I have no doubt in my mind that i'll enjoy the single player of MGS4 much more than H3(lol not much to brag about). GTA4's single player was great but had some really annoying flaws and glitches.

Stop reading reviews people.
Can I keep you?
15
66% Ranking 66% Ranking 66% Ranking 66% Ranking
+1 Frags
+   -

mgs4 and portable ops are the only ones I cant own :( would make my collection complete
Spiral out, keep going. Spiral out, keep going. Spiral out, keep going.
16
128% Ranking 128% Ranking 128% Ranking 128% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Never base purchases on reviews; unless they're all horrible a la Haze.
17
122% Ranking 122% Ranking 122% Ranking 122% Ranking
+2 Frags
+   -

Halo got a 10 based on name alone, the game itself was more like a 7
Squeegee your third eye.
18
12% Ranking 12% Ranking 12% Ranking 12% Ranking
+3 Frags
+   -

# 17 more like a 6,5 , CoD4 was by far way better FPS than Halo
19
55% Ranking 55% Ranking 55% Ranking 55% Ranking
GotFrag Prime!
+1 Frags
+   -

yada yada yada
Gamertag: passmoreNOPE ~ team backdraft
20
44% Ranking 44% Ranking 44% Ranking 44% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Who cares about that some review site says. As long as you enjoy it who cares.
21
14% Ranking 14% Ranking 14% Ranking 14% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

People just want another reason to start another "z0mg 360>ps3?!?!?" thread.

#7 Has it.

If your a fan, nothing matters.
22
53% Ranking 53% Ranking 53% Ranking 53% Ranking
+1 Frags
+   -

halo 3 sucks
#momentum.cs
23
51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking
-4 Frags
+   -

QUOTE:
halo 3 sucks


If H3 sucks so bad, how did it manage to shatter sale records when it came out? The Halo franchise was Epic, and very important to FPS on consoles.
AMD Opteron 180 @ 2.8ghz Air | Evga 8800GTS | 2GB G.SKill DDR
24
86% Ranking 86% Ranking 86% Ranking 86% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

#23 it did so well just by being named Halo and by having a pretty good multiplayer. The first Halo was the only one with a good single player.
I don't even have a PS3, but I refuse to believe H3 is better than MGS4, <insert hype>
25
66% Ranking 66% Ranking 66% Ranking 66% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

the bigger question is what do the halo 3 reviews have got to do with mgs4 reviews.
Spiral out, keep going. Spiral out, keep going. Spiral out, keep going.
26
13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

It was a joke. Edge gave Halo3 a 10, and MGS4 an 8. MGS4 will obviously be the better game, as Halo3 is a piece of crap.

#23 Hype
"GTA4 ALL 10's" - IGN
27
20% Ranking 20% Ranking 20% Ranking 20% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Too bad Halo3 and MGS4 have completly different gameplay.
28
51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking 51% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

H3 sold big, because Halo is a massive franchise that millions of people like. I love the Halo games, and think the MGS games suck horribly, that's my preference.

H3 has a huge advantage over every console game except COD4 in multiplayer, that's why it go such rave reviews, plus all the added features, and replay value of it. More people play the Halo games online for consoles then any other game i would bet.

This comment was edited at 06/01/2008 6:37 PM
AMD Opteron 180 @ 2.8ghz Air | Evga 8800GTS | 2GB G.SKill DDR
29
13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking 13% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

way more people play cod4 than h3
"GTA4 ALL 10's" - IGN
30
19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking 19% Ranking
0 Frags
+   -

Halo sucks, it shoulda been the RTS-y thing on the myth engine, that woulda been cool.
31
<